The Bestseller Code, by Jodie Archer and Matthew Jockers, St Martin’s Press, 2016, comes to some unexpected conclusions. The book was reviewed by Sandra Elliot in the June issue of The Florida Writer.
“Through an analysis of recent best sellers, Authors Jodie Archer and Matthew Jockers claim to have identified the elements that move a novel to the top in sales. They begin with an overview of what makes people read, including insights and quotes from Stephen King’s On Writing. He says no one really knows what makes a story a hit, and advises would-be professionals to choose topics they know and blend in others like relationships, sex and work. The Bestseller Code authors arouse reader interest by debunking King’s adages. No sex in popular novels? No, they say, and use their research findings to support their statements.
“. . . One of their first questions: themes that promote or limit a story’s commercial popularity. Sex, drugs and rock and roll are among those tested and found wanting. Few bestsellers are based on these themes. What about Fifty Shades of Grey? . . . Not the sex, they say, but a living, breathing side of the narrative that readers feel it like the thrum of nightclub music. The Da Vinci Code is the only other book to have such a powerful rhythm, they add.
“. . . (The book) identified John Grisham and Danielle Steel as authors who used themes of interest to many readers. Grisham’s signature theme is ‘Lawyers and the Law’, Steel’s ‘Domestic Life’.
“Overall, bestselling authors allocate a third of their novels to one or two themes; less successful authors include more. . . . These findings are particularly relevant for debut writers who tend to write about too much. An in-depth story is easier to follow than writing heavy with description and detail. More women than men gain popularity with their debut novels. Does a feminine writing style have payoff? No, it’s not gender but an understanding of audience and language that pays, that, and the nurturing of skills through practice.
“Gender differences were noted. Protagonists in recent female-oriented novels are internally complex and externally challenged, odd or different gals with power and motivation. Characters in bestselling novels, male or female, are high-energy people who set out to achieve what they want to be.”
A three star review by EVS on Amazon.com says, in part: “I found myself simultaneously impressed with the depth of the research and disappointed with the triviality of the findings. Moreover, as much as the authors hope that their formula will open publishing industry to new writers overlooked otherwise, I have a feeling it will only serve to build more, higher walls, imprisoning writers in even tighter cells. Ironically, what would mediate the potential for abuse is making the formula available to the public in the form of a readily accessible test. It’s just the question of time until application of this or similar math becomes obligatory among agents and publishers. If the potential success or failure of an artist’s project is going to depend on a formula, the artist should have the right to face his accuser.”
I tend to share EVS concerns about agents and publishers using this, or a more ‘perfect’ algorithm in selecting works for publication and thereby building higher walls and imprisoning writers in even tighter cells. But, I also guess that it will indeed be helpful in coaching overlooked authors to better hit the mark. And I suspect that, in any case, there will always be a writer who finds a route to success that the algorithm overlooks.
In view of all this, I am motivated to get a copy of the book and report to you in more detail.