I bought a copy of this historical novel written by Lisa Wingate. Ms Wingate’s long bio reads, in part: “Lisa Wingate is the author of the #1 New York Times bestseller Before We Were Yours, which remained on the bestseller list for fifty-four weeks in hardcover and has sold over 2 million copies. She has penned over thirty novels and coauthored a nonfiction book, Before and After with Judy Christie. Her award-winning works have been selected for state and community One Book reads throughout the country, have been published in over forty languages, and have appeared on bestseller lists worldwide. Booklist summed up her work by saying, “Lisa Wingate is, quite simply, a master storyteller.”
Before We Were Yours is a historical novel written in two parts. One part is set along the Mississippi River, near Memphis, in the late 1930’s and early ’40’s. The second part, in Georgia, is more contemporary. The first part centers on a family of ‘river gypsies’ who live in a shanty boat on the river. The parents are Briny and Queenie Foss; their five children are Rill, the narrator, a girl of twelve and the oldest, Camilla, Lark, Fern and Gabion, a male toddler. The story begins with Queenie in the throes of giving a difficult birth to twins. Briny takes her to the hospital in Memphis, leaving the children on the boat in Rill’s care. All five children are abducted and taken into care by the Tennessee Children’s Home Society, a real abduction and orphanage mill which made an estimated $10 million for it’s real owner, Georgia Tann, and was active from the 1920’s until it was shut down in 1950. It made a habit of taking children into custody on false premises and placing them in wealthy, childless families. Most of the first part deals with the hardships faced by the Foss children as they wait for a family to take them away: first Gabion, then Camilla is separated and disappears, then Lark. Rill and Fern escape from the family that took them in, only to find that Queenie is dead in the childbirth and Briny is mortally crippled with drink. Rill and Fern return voluntarily to their assigned parents.
The second part is told by Avery, single in her 30’s, who turns out to be the granddaughter of one of Queenie’s twins, who survived, and was also taken in by the Tennessee Children’s Home Society and adopted. The grandmother, Judy, now in her 70’s and suffering from dementia, is the widow of a Stafford, who are a dynasty of Georgia senators. Avery is being prepped to run for the Senate, replacing her father, who is ill. She meets May Crandall, who is in her 90’s and in a nursing home, during a pre-campaign visit to the nursing home. May, we discover later, is Rill. Much of the second part is taken up with Avery, being assisted by the grandson of a friend of Judy’s, trying to piece together her family history.
Ms Wingate is clearly a talented writer. She describes her characters and the life on a shanty boat so clearly that they are real. She is also a master at keeping the reader turning pages, a one suffers anxiety about what happens next. The story itself is heart-rendingly captivating.
In my view, though, the novel has its flaws. In the first part, there are too many chapters, with too much detail, about the hardships the Foss children endured, while they were awaiting adoption. I think the story would be stronger if it were edited down, In the second part, there are secondary issues that aren’t well enough developed to stand alongside the children’s story: the effect that disclosure of their real heritage would have on the Stafford name, and Avery’s decision about whom to marry. There are also too many family events that do not really contribute to character development or the plot. More rigorous editing would have made this a memorable novel.