The Reader Views Blog has an article by Sheri Hoyte, Managing Editor, regarding the process of scoring titles for the Reader Views Reviewers Choice Literary Awards. Sheri Hoyte’s website says that she is an aspiring children’s picture book author. “I worked in the corporate world for over thirty years, honing my business and professional writing skills until 2012, when my passion for stories called me home to Reader Views an online publicity company for authors. Over the next couple of years I read and reviewed books for Reader Views, becoming the editor and social media manager in 2014. I am now one of the managing editors.”
In the blog she says: “So what do judges look for when scoring a literary awards title? Much like reading with a writer’s hat on, reading with a judge’s hat takes a different focus. Following are the guidelines I use when judging a literary awards title:
· Content. Does the author’s voice convey a distinct and consistent style throughout? Does the flow of the book draw the reader in at an appropriate pace? Does the reader have a clear understanding of who the characters are in the story?
· Presentation and Design. There is nothing more distracting to a great story than editing and proofreading errors. This is the easiest thing to fix or prevent in the first place. I can tell within the first few pages whether or not a professional editor has been used. An occasional typo won’t make or break the book, but consistent use of poor grammar will cost points in the presentation category.
· Production Quality. Is the cover attractive and appropriate for the genre and the story? Yes, I know the cliché, but a dull and drab cover, or a noisy cover with hidden titles and too much information can be a turn off. Does the binding fall apart when opening the book? Is the paper quality adequate or just so-so? I have a hard time concentrating on a story when the book I’m reading is falling apart or the pages are tearing because the paper is so thin.
· Innovation. To stand out in any genre, innovation is the key. Is the subject matter original? Does the author bring a fresh voice to the genre? Are writing elements being used in interesting and creative ways?
· Social Relevance and Enjoyment. For fiction books: Is the book impactful on the community of the genre? Is it reflective of important social issues? Is it highly entertaining and completely engrossing? Would I re-read this book? Was I left wanting more?
· Resourcefulness. For self-help, business, how-to, etc. type of books: Is the book easy to follow, clear and concise? Are credible sources noted? Does the author have credibility in the subject matter?
When I read a book, whether for pure enjoyment, to learn a new skill, expand my knowledge, or for a literary contest, I want to feel a connection to that book. Fiction or non-fiction, humorous or biographical, when I’ve finished a book and it lingers in my mind for days – that is the sign of greatness.